Imagine dropping thousands of dollars on a single night’s stay at a hotel. Sounds extravagant, right? Well, that’s exactly what I did when I checked into the Aman New York, the city’s most talked-about and jaw-droppingly expensive hotel. But here’s where it gets controversial: is it truly worth the hype—and the price tag? Let’s dive in.
Nestled within the iconic Crown Building at 57th and 5th, the 83-suite Aman New York has been the subject of endless curiosity since its 2022 opening. With rates starting at a staggering $2,400 to $3,200 per night (taxes and fees included), it’s not just a hotel—it’s a statement. But does it deliver on its promise of unparalleled luxury? The answer is a nuanced yes and no.
On the bright side, the hotel is a masterpiece of design and intimacy. Jean-Michel Gathy, the genius behind many Aman properties, has crafted interiors that defy expectations. While the 14th-floor lobby feels intentionally dim, the rooms are a burst of brightness and elegance. Each suite starts at a sprawling 718 square feet, featuring long entryways, massive bathrooms with soaking tubs and bidets, and closets that could double as small apartments. The bedroom area, with its impeccable wall finishes and cozy fireplace, feels like a sanctuary where no expense was spared. And let’s not forget the unbelievable wellness area—25,000 square feet of pure indulgence, including a 65-foot indoor pool, a state-of-the-art gym, and a full-service spa. The dining options, exclusive to guests, residents, and Aman Club members, are equally impressive. From the all-day Lounge Bar to the Italian-inspired Arva and the sushi haven Nama, the food is exceptional—and surprisingly reasonably priced for this level of luxury.
But here’s where it gets controversial: for all its grandeur, the Aman New York doesn’t quite live up to the legendary service that has made Aman resorts in Asia so iconic. Don’t get me wrong—the staff is friendly and well-intentioned, but there’s a lack of that anticipatory, almost telepathic service that Amanjunkies rave about. For instance, a simple request for ice took 55 minutes to fulfill, with no apology or acknowledgment of the delay. At these prices, you’d expect flawless execution.
And this is the part most people miss: the Aman New York isn’t trying to replicate the traditional Aman resort experience. It’s a city hotel, and it excels in that role. The room size, amenities, and inclusions (like a fully stocked minibar, breakfast, and a house car) make it a strong contender for the best hotel in New York—if you can afford it. But if you’re seeking the quintessential Aman experience, you’re better off heading to one of their Asian properties.
So, is the Aman New York worth it? For those who demand the absolute best and don’t bat an eye at the price, absolutely. For everyone else, it’s a fascinating glimpse into the world of ultra-luxury—but perhaps not a must-stay. What’s your take? Is the Aman New York a masterpiece worth the splurge, or does it fall short of its lofty promises? Let’s debate in the comments!
